The Kelowna, B.C., nursing pupil seen in an condo surveillance video being dragged by an RCMP officer down a hallway earlier than being stepped on throughout a wellness test says police ought to be accompanied by a well being skilled. 

“I believed, ‘What is going on to occur after this? The place am I speculated to go when the people who find themselves supposed to guard you’re the ones which might be abusing you?'” Mona Wang, 20, mentioned in an interview with CBC about her expertise.

On January 20, Wang, who says she has historical past of tension, was having a panic assault. She had been in touch together with her boyfriend in Vancouver, however when she stopped responding to his texts, he received frightened and referred to as emergency responders to check out her.

“I had self-harmed somewhat bit and drank two glasses of wine and ingested some medicine. I wasn’t actually in the very best state because of the alcohol and [the medication],” she mentioned. 

RCMP officer Cpl. Lacy Browning arrived alone at Wang’s Kelowna rental to do the wellness test. 

In her discover of declare, Wang alleges Browning used extreme power through the test, at one level punching Wang and leaving her with bruises on her face, whereas shouting at her “to cease being so dramatic.” Surveillance video later reveals Browning dragging Wang throughout the hallway, and later, stepping on her head. 

“So many individuals within the constructing have been strolling previous, folks I see every day. It felt so humiliating and so degrading,” Wang mentioned. 

“I used to be of no risk to her. I had my palms cuffed behind my again, laying on the ground on my abdomen.” 

The RCMP have denied the allegations and say Browning used affordable power given the circumstances. In Browning’s assertion of defence, she alleges Wang had a field cutter in her hand.

After she eliminated the knife, Browning claims the coed was initially unresponsive however then grew to become combative, and began yelling that she wished to be killed.

“The defendant Browning then struck the plaintiff a number of instances with an open palm, which subdued the plaintiff sufficiently for the defendant Browning to efficiently handcuff the plaintiff,” the authorized response states.

Wang denies she was holding a field cutter, saying it was throughout the room.

The case remains to be earlier than the courts. 

Watch Mona Wang discuss to CBC’s Lien Yeung about her expertise:

Mona Wang advised CBC’s Lien Yeung about her expertise with police throughout a January wellness test. 3:21

Rising variety of psychological well being calls to police

The police say the variety of psychological well being calls officers have had to answer has grown exponentially lately.

Brenda Lucki, the RCMP commissioner, mentioned RCMP have an essential function to play in these conditions. 

“When somebody is holding a knife and affected by a psychological well being disaster, that’s not the time to be bringing in psychological well being practitioners,” she mentioned through the Home of Commons public security and nationwide safety committee assembly Tuesday.

“It is time for the RCMP to go in, get that individual calm, get them to a spot of security and get them the assistance they want.”

In Surrey, RCMP say they responded to 7,000 psychological well being calls in 2019. The detachment has made an try to higher reply to those calls by creating the Automobile 67 program. In it, a psychological well being nurse is paired with an officer to attend sure calls. 

Cpl. Scotty Schumann, an officer with this system, says it’s disheartening to see folks fighting psychological well being points and never getting the assistance they want. He additionally famous the experience of the nurse in particular conditions. 

“There’s positively instances when, with out the nurse, we might have apprehended somebody not recognizing the indicators of a psychological well being difficulty,” Schumann mentioned. 

Wang says pairing a police officer with a psychological well being skilled might assist. (Ben Nelms/CBC)

Wang says that sort of pairing may very well be a great way to stop what occurred to her.

“I do not consider that cops ought to go alone to a wellness test,” she mentioned. “[And] I believe it is essential for a psychological well being nurse or a social employee or another sort of allied well being to accompany police … as a result of they’ve the talents wanted.”

Referring to her personal coaching, Wang says nurses are particularly taught to make use of de-escalation methods with out resorting to power. 

“We have now combative and aggressive sufferers on a regular basis,” she mentioned. “It is telling them that your emotions are legitimate and talking by means of it.”

Renewed scrutiny on wellness checks

Wang will not be the one one calling for vital change to wellness checks. Her case and others have put elevated scrutiny on the function of the police in coping with psychological well being crises.  

Because the starting of April this 12 months, at the least 4 folks have died in Canada through the course of a police-involved wellness checks.  

  • D’Andre Campbell, a 26-year-old Black man with schizophrenia, was shot useless on April 6 in Brampton, Ont., after calling Peel Regional Police himself for assist. 
  • Regis Korchinski-Paquet, 29, a Black-Indigenous girl, died after falling from a high-rise balcony in Toronto after her household referred to as the police for assistance on Could 27.
  • In New Brunswick, Chantel Moore, a 26-year-old Indigenous girl, was shot and killed by an officer on June four throughout a wellness test.
  • And on June 20, Ejaz Ahmed Choudry, a 62-year-old Pakistani immigrant who had schizophrenia, was shot and killed by police in Mississauga, Ont., throughout a wellness test.

Meenakshi Mannoe, with the Pivot Authorized Society, says society wants to take a look at how all the psychological well being system is failing folks as much as and together with the second police go to their dwelling for a wellness test. (Martin Diotte/CBC)

Meenakshi Mannoe, with Vancouver’s Pivot Authorized Society, says she’s not stunned by these tales, citing previous deaths within the Decrease Mainland resembling Tony Du, a 51-year-old man who was shot by police in 2014 after brandishing a two-by-four at a Vancouver intersection, and Kyaw Naing Din, who was killed in his Maple Ridge, B.C. dwelling in 2019. Each males had psychological diseases.

Mannoe says using police to take care of psychological well being crises reveals that too many individuals are being failed by the psychological well being system. 

“For folk that contact the RCMP for a wellness test or any sort of test or any sort of police authority, it represents the failure of neighborhood companies. It’s folks at their wits finish about who to name,” she mentioned.

She mentioned there must be extra help — and funding — for peer-support staff, counsellors and well being professionals. 

“It is so essential that we reply to folks empathetically and likewise in culturally-safe, trauma-informed methods slightly than use of power or doubtlessly deadly use of power.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here