Top Court Stays Proceedings In Cases Against Scribes In West Bengal

“Difficulty discover. Additional proceedings in pursuance to the FIRs are stayed,” bench stated in its order.

New Delhi:

The Supreme Courtroom Friday stayed additional proceedings in three FIRs lodged in West Bengal towards some individuals, together with editors of a information internet portal, relating to articles revealed by them.

The highest court docket additionally issued notices to the West Bengal authorities and the Centre searching for their replies on a plea filed by Nupur J Sharma, the editor of English language, and others together with its founder and CEO.

“Difficulty discover. Additional proceedings in pursuance to the FIRs are stayed,” a bench comprising Justices SK Kaul and BR Gavai stated in its order.

The bench was listening to a petition filed by Sharma and others together with the founder and CEO of reports portal and editor of its Hindi language publications who’ve claimed that the West Bengal authorities and its “authoritarian Kolkata Police” is misusing FIRs and “brute police-powers” to intimidate journalists.

The petitioners have been represented within the prime court docket by senior advocate Mahesh Jethmalani and lawyer Sandeep Kapur.

“The petitioners are constrained to invoke the extra-ordinary writ jurisdiction of this court docket below Article 32 of the Structure towards the patently extortionist and mala fide actions of the Authorities of West Bengal to impose unlawful censorship within the state by threatening, scuttling, and gagging trustworthy media homes by means of misuse of state police,” the plea claimed.

The petitioners claimed they have been knowledgeable that reason behind one of many FIRs lodged by police was an article revealed by the information internet portal on the problem of alleged hiding of knowledge associated to COVID-19.

The plea claimed that one of many FIRs lodged pertained to information report revealed by the net portal in October final yr.

It alleged that to undermine the liberty of press, the state has fairly chosen to “hound down” the petitioners by registering a number of FIRs to be able to “discount for deletion of reports articles by placing the petitioner’s life and liberty at bait”.

It claimed the state and the police usually are not solely intimidating the journalists, but additionally threatening their members of the family to hunt deletion of media studies which convey to the general public discover “the precise state of affairs within the state of West Bengal throughout these tough occasions”.

The plea alleged that whereas the authorities are utilizing FIRs to “scuttle free speech” and issuing notices to the petitioners, the police has regardless of repeated requests refused to share the copy of those FIRs or to add the identical on their official web site.

“What’s obvious is the style during which the powers below the Code of Felony Process (CrPC) and the investigative powers of the police, are being blatantly misused by the state of West Bengal (Respondent No. 1) to scuttle and silence bonafide however important situations of journalism, able to inflicting inconvenience to its political executives, in complete disregard to the constitutional ensures contained in Articles 19(1)(a) and 21 of the Structure,” it stated.

It alleged that the police had intimidated a few of the petitioners to get the information articles deleted.

“Accordingly, the officers whereas insulting and demeaning the petitioner no. 1, requested her to make use of her affect to get the articles eliminated or to face the brunt of state’s political executives,” it claimed.

The plea claimed that deleting any content material from the web has a nationwide impact and any resolution to delete any content material needs to be left to be taken by the Centre and never by state governments.

It has additionally sought a route to exclude the function of police within the matter of deletion of content material on the web “notably since there exists regulatory mechanism for overseeing such content material” and limiting any mischievous contents.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here